| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica35 | Start of 1st quarter, clock 15:00. |
| | | * Utica wins the toss and will defer. IC receives kick. |
| | | Dan Tette kickoff 63 yards to the ITHACA2, R. D'Amico return 32 yards to the ITHACA34 (Dan Tette). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca34 | W. Nabi pass complete to J. Jarvis for 6 yards to the ITHACA40 (Matthew McCoy;Antonio Scala). |
| Ithaca | 2-4 | at Ithaca40 | W. Nabi pass complete to H. Frey for 21 yards to the UTICA39, 1ST DOWN ITHACA, out-of-bounds (Daryl Savage). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica39 | A. Vito rush for loss of 1 yard to the UTICA40 (Dehstin Smart). |
| Ithaca | 2-11 | at Utica40 | K. Anderson rush for 3 yards to the UTICA37 (Antonio Scala;Robbie Schempp). |
| Ithaca | 3-8 | at Utica37 | W. Nabi pass complete to N. Cervone for 5 yards to the UTICA32 (Matthew McCoy). |
| Ithaca | 4-3 | at Utica32 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to W. Gladney, dropped pass (Dehstin Smart). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 34 yards, TOP 02:35 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica32 | UTICA drive start at 12:25. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica32 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 2 yards to the UTICA34 (R. Bronson;G. Repicky). |
| Utica | 2-8 | at Utica34 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Peyton Miller. |
| Utica | 3-8 | at Utica34 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Josh Connor for 36 yards to the ITHACA30, 1ST DOWN UTICA (R. D'Amico), PENALTY ITHACA offside declined. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca30 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 4 yards to the ITHACA26 (N. Garone;R. Bronson). |
| Utica | 2-6 | at Ithaca26 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Brad Dougherty for 3 yards to the ITHACA23 (A. Francis). |
| Utica | 3-3 | at Ithaca23 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 8 yards to the ITHACA15, 1ST DOWN UTICA (N. Garone;C. McDermott). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca15 | Peyton Miller rush for 10 yards to the ITHACA5, out-of-bounds (C. McDermott;N. Garone), PENALTY UTICA holding (Malcolm Stowe) 10 yards to the ITHACA25, NO PLAY. |
| Utica | 1-20 | at Ithaca25 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Alex Damiani, QB hurry by M. Barbieri. |
| Utica | 2-20 | at Ithaca25 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Peyton Miller for 8 yards to the ITHACA17 (R. D'Amico). |
| Utica | 3-12 | at Ithaca17 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Peyton Miller for 14 yards to the ITHACA3, 1ST DOWN UTICA (R. Silva). |
| Utica | 1-G | at Ithaca03 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 3 yards to the ITHACA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:53, Maki Medici kick attempt good. |
| | | Utica 7, Ithaca College 0 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 68 yards, TOP 04:37 |
| | | Dan Tette kickoff 60 yards to the ITHACA5, R. D'Amico return 16 yards to the ITHACA21 (D. Sekuterski;Joshua Fenical). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca21 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 07:48. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca21 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to W. Gladney (Matthew McCoy), QB hurry by Andrew Caruso. |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Ithaca21 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to A. Vito (Kwasi Addo). |
| Ithaca | 3-10 | at Ithaca21 | W. Nabi pass complete to J. Cooney for 79 yards to the UTICA0, 1ST DOWN ITHACA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:26. |
| | | K. Berna rush attempt good. |
| | | Ithaca College 8, Utica 7 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 79 yards, TOP 00:34 |
| | | B. Fallon kickoff 58 yards to the UTICA7, Marquis Simpson return 15 yards to the UTICA22 (M. Haynes), PENALTY UTICA illegal block 10 yards to the UTICA12, 1st and 10, UTICA ball on UTICA12. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica12 | UTICA drive start at 07:14. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica12 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 9 yards to the UTICA21 (M. Barbieri). |
| Utica | 2-1 | at Utica21 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 2 yards to the UTICA23, 1ST DOWN UTICA (N. Garone;R. Silva). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica23 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Imani Vincent for 12 yards to the UTICA35, 1ST DOWN UTICA. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica35 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 3 yards to the UTICA38 (P. McNeeley). |
| Utica | 2-7 | at Utica38 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 8 yards to the UTICA46, 1ST DOWN UTICA (C. McDermott). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica46 | Brad Dougherty rush for 4 yards to the 50 yardline (R. Bronson;J. Hadac). |
| Utica | 2-6 | at Utica50 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Alex Damiani, dropped pass (M. Barbieri). |
| Utica | 3-6 | at Utica50 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Imani Vincent, dropped pass (J. Long). |
| Utica | 4-6 | at Utica50 | Maki Medici punt 36 yards to the ITHACA14, fair catch by A. Vito. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 38 yards, TOP 03:45 |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca14 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 03:29. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca14 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to W. Gladney (A. Beaubrun). |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Ithaca14 | K. Anderson rush for 9 yards to the ITHACA23, out-of-bounds (Elijah Belle), PENALTY ITHACA holding (J. Jarvis) 10 yards to the ITHACA13. |
| Ithaca | 2-11 | at Ithaca13 | N. Cervone rush for 3 yards to the ITHACA16 (Keanu Heedram;Kevin Chisari). |
| Ithaca | 3-8 | at Ithaca16 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 10 yards to the ITHACA26, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Dehstin Smart;Kwasi Addo). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca26 | K. Anderson rush for 2 yards to the ITHACA28 (Kwasi Addo;Shane Walpole). |
| Ithaca | 2-8 | at Ithaca28 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to H. Frey (Matthew McCoy). |
| Ithaca | 3-8 | at Ithaca28 | W. Nabi pass complete to J. Cooney for 18 yards to the ITHACA46, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Matthew McCoy). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca46 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 11 yards to the UTICA43, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Matthew McCoy). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica43 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to A. Vito (Andrew Caruso). |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Utica43 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 43 yards to the UTICA0, 1ST DOWN ITHACA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:00, B. Fallon kick attempt good. |
| | | Ithaca College 15, Utica 7 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 86 yards, TOP 03:36 |
| | | Ithaca College 15, Utica 7 |
| Ithaca | 1-G | at Ithaca35 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 86 yards, TOP 03:36 |
| | | B. Fallon kickoff 46 yards to the UTICA19, Tim Hogan return 16 yards to the UTICA35 (D. Nieto;M. Roumes). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica35 | UTICA drive start at 14:53. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica35 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 11 yards to the UTICA46, 1ST DOWN UTICA (N. Garone). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica46 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 2 yards to the UTICA48 (M. Riccitelli;R. Bronson). |
| Utica | 2-8 | at Utica48 | Malcolm Stowe rush for loss of 1 yard to the UTICA47 (B. Gill). |
| Utica | 3-9 | at Utica47 | PENALTY UTICA false start (Dan Busold) 5 yards to the UTICA42. |
| Utica | 3-14 | at Utica42 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Brad Dougherty for 4 yards to the UTICA46 (B. Gill;A. Francis). |
| Utica | 4-10 | at Utica46 | Maki Medici punt 52 yards to the ITHACA2, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 11 yards, TOP 02:41 |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca02 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 12:12. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca02 | I. D'Haiti rush for loss of 2 yards to the ITHACA0 (Kwasi Addo), Kwasi Addo safety, clock 12:07, PENALTY UTICA offside defense (M. Curcurito) 5 yards to the ITHACA7, NO PLAY. |
| Ithaca | 1-5 | at Ithaca07 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to W. Gladney. |
| Ithaca | 2-5 | at Ithaca07 | I. D'Haiti rush for no gain to the ITHACA7 (Antonio Scala). |
| Ithaca | 3-5 | at Ithaca07 | W. Nabi pass complete to D. Garcia for 2 yards to the ITHACA9 (A. Beaubrun). |
| Ithaca | 4-3 | at Ithaca09 | P. Minogue punt 20 yards to the ITHACA29, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards, TOP 01:47 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca29 | UTICA drive start at 10:25. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca29 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Peyton Miller, dropped pass (C. McDermott). |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Ithaca29 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Peyton Miller for 4 yards to the ITHACA25 (C. McDermott). |
| Utica | 3-6 | at Ithaca25 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 4 yards to the ITHACA21 (M. Barbieri;A. Valle). |
| Utica | 4-2 | at Ithaca21 | Malcolm Stowe rush for no gain to the ITHACA21 (C. McDermott). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:27 |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca21 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 08:58. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca21 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to D. Garcia, dropped pass. |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Ithaca21 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to J. Cooney. |
| Ithaca | 3-10 | at Ithaca21 | W. Nabi pass complete to A. Vito for 4 yards to the ITHACA25 (A. Beaubrun;Kwasi Addo). |
| Ithaca | 4-6 | at Ithaca25 | P. Minogue punt 36 yards to the UTICA39, fair catch by Nate Palmer. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 00:59 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica39 | UTICA drive start at 07:59. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica39 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 5 yards to the UTICA44 (P. Minogue;B. Gill). |
| Utica | 2-5 | at Utica44 | Malcolm Stowe rush for 4 yards to the UTICA48, out-of-bounds (R. Bronson;A. Francis). |
| Utica | 3-1 | at Utica48 | Malcolm Stowe rush for no gain to the UTICA48 (J. Hadac;N. Hill). |
| Utica | 4-1 | at Utica48 | Maki Medici rush for loss of 15 yards to the UTICA33 (A. Francis). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 6 yards, TOP 02:00 |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica33 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 05:59. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica33 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 33 yards to the UTICA0, 1ST DOWN ITHACA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:54. |
| Ithaca | 1-G | at Utica03 | PENALTY ITHACA unsportsmanlike conduct (W. Gladney) 17 yards to the UTICA20. |
| | | B. Fallon kick attempt failed, PENALTY UTICA roughing the kicker 5 yards to the UTICA15, NO PLAY. |
| | | B. Fallon kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Andrew Caruso). |
| | | Ithaca College 21, Utica 7 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 33 yards, TOP 00:12 |
| | | B. Fallon kickoff 54 yards to the UTICA11, Marquis Simpson return 32 yards to the UTICA43 (K. Brown;A. Valle). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica43 | UTICA drive start at 05:47. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica43 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Imani Vincent for 12 yards to the ITHACA45, 1ST DOWN UTICA, out-of-bounds (R. Bronson;A. Francis). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca45 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Malcolm Stowe. |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Ithaca45 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Peyton Miller for 7 yards to the ITHACA38, out-of-bounds (A. Francis). |
| Utica | 3-3 | at Ithaca38 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Imani Vincent for 17 yards to the ITHACA21, 1ST DOWN UTICA (B. Pacholec). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca21 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Peyton Miller, dropped pass (C. McDermott). |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Ithaca21 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Malcolm Stowe. |
| Utica | 3-10 | at Ithaca21 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Peyton Miller, QB hurry by B. Pacholec. |
| Utica | 4-10 | at Ithaca21 | Maki Medici field goal attempt from 38 MISSED - short, spot at ITHACA20, clock 04:04. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 36 yards, TOP 01:43 |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca20 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 04:04. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca20 | K. Anderson rush for 3 yards to the ITHACA23 (Robbie Schempp). |
| Ithaca | 2-7 | at Ithaca23 | Timeout Utica, clock 03:58. |
| Ithaca | 2-7 | at Ithaca23 | W. Nabi pass intercepted by Kwasi Addo at the ITHACA25, Kwasi Addo return 25 yards to the ITHACA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:49. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:15 |
| | | Maki Medici kick attempt good. |
| | | Ithaca College 21, Utica 14 |
| | | Dan Tette kickoff 60 yards to the ITHACA5, R. D'Amico return 14 yards to the ITHACA19 (Sean Murphy;John Nish). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca19 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 03:43. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca19 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 16 yards to the ITHACA35, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Antonio Scala;Keanu Heedram). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca35 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to J. Jarvis, dropped pass (Dehstin Smart). |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Ithaca35 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 4 yards to the ITHACA39 (Antonio Scala;Jack Derby). |
| Ithaca | 3-6 | at Ithaca39 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to J. Cooney, dropped pass. |
| Ithaca | 4-6 | at Ithaca39 | P. Minogue punt 14 yards to the UTICA47, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 20 yards, TOP 01:17 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica47 | UTICA drive start at 02:26. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica47 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Imani Vincent for 6 yards to the ITHACA47 (N. Garone). |
| Utica | 2-4 | at Ithaca47 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Imani Vincent for 15 yards to the ITHACA32, 1ST DOWN UTICA, out-of-bounds (R. Bronson). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca32 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Imani Vincent, QB hurry by N. Garone. |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Ithaca32 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Nate Palmer (C. McDermott). |
| Utica | 3-10 | at Ithaca32 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Peyton Miller for 17 yards to the ITHACA15, 1ST DOWN UTICA (R. Silva). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca15 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Peyton Miller for 15 yards to the ITHACA0, 1ST DOWN UTICA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:15, Maki Medici kick attempt good. |
| | | Utica 21, Ithaca College 21 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 53 yards, TOP 01:11 |
| | | Dan Tette kickoff 65 yards to the ITHACA0, touchback. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca25 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 01:15. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca25 | W. Nabi pass complete to N. Cervone for 10 yards to the ITHACA35, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Elijah Belle), PENALTY UTICA roughing passer (Robbie Schempp) 15 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN ITHACA. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca50 | 1st and 10. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca50 | W. Nabi pass complete to A. Vito for 12 yards to the UTICA38, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Daryl Savage), PENALTY UTICA personal foul 15 yards to the UTICA23, 1ST DOWN ITHACA. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica23 | 1st and 10. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica23 | Timeout Utica, clock 01:00. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica23 | H. Frey pass incomplete to W. Nabi. |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Utica23 | W. Nabi pass complete to J. Cooney for 23 yards to the UTICA0, 1ST DOWN ITHACA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:46, B. Fallon kick attempt good. |
| | | Ithaca College 28, Utica 21 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 75 yards, TOP 00:34 |
| | | B. Fallon kickoff 50 yards to the UTICA15, Marquis Simpson return 17 yards to the UTICA32 (R. D'Amico). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica32 | UTICA drive start at 00:41. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica32 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Imani Vincent for 15 yards to the UTICA47, 1ST DOWN UTICA (A. Francis). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica47 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Imani Vincent for 9 yards to the ITHACA44 (A. Francis). |
| Utica | 2-1 | at Ithaca44 | TEAM pass incomplete. |
| Utica | 3-1 | at Ithaca44 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Brad Dougherty for 4 yards to the ITHACA40, 1ST DOWN UTICA, out-of-bounds (A. Francis). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca40 | Logan Wilcox rush for 3 yards to the ITHACA37, out-of-bounds. |
| Utica | 2-7 | at Ithaca37 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Josh Connor for 12 yards to the ITHACA25, 1ST DOWN UTICA (R. Bronson;R. Silva). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca25 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 43 yards, TOP 00:41 |
| | | Ithaca College 28, Utica 21 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca25 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, ITHACA ball on ITHACA35. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 43 yards, TOP 00:41 |
| | | B. Fallon kickoff 52 yards to the UTICA13, Tim Hogan return 7 yards to the UTICA20 (R. D'Amico). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica20 | UTICA drive start at 14:56. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica20 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Peyton Miller. |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Utica20 | Brad Dougherty rush for loss of 1 yard to the UTICA19 (N. Hill;B. Gill). |
| Utica | 3-11 | at Utica19 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Josh Connor for 11 yards to the UTICA30 (R. D'Amico;R. Bronson), QB hurry by J. Hadac, PENALTY UTICA illegal block (Nate Palmer) 10 yards to the UTICA20. |
| Utica | 3-10 | at Utica20 | 3rd and 10. |
| Utica | 3-10 | at Utica20 | Logan Wilcox sacked for loss of 9 yards to the UTICA11 (J. Hadac;A. Valle). |
| Utica | 4-19 | at Utica11 | Maki Medici punt 40 yards to the ITHACA49, A. Vito return 0 yards to the ITHACA49, fumble by A. Vito recovered by UTICA D. Sekuterski at ITHACA49, D. Sekuterski for 3 yards to the ITHACA46. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 9 yards, TOP 01:59 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca46 | UTICA drive start at 12:57, UTICA ball on ITHACA46. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca46 | I. Washington rush for 2 yards to the ITHACA44 (J. Long). |
| Utica | 2-8 | at Ithaca44 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Josh Connor for 23 yards to the ITHACA21, 1ST DOWN UTICA (J. Long;C. McDermott). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca21 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Alex Damiani for 15 yards to the ITHACA6, 1ST DOWN UTICA (P. Minogue;J. Long). |
| Utica | 1-G | at Ithaca06 | I. Washington rush for 1 yard to the ITHACA5 (M. Barbieri;N. Garone). |
| Utica | 2-G | at Ithaca05 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Imani Vincent (A. Francis). |
| Utica | 3-G | at Ithaca05 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Peyton Miller (J. Long). |
| Utica | 4-G | at Ithaca05 | Maki Medici field goal attempt from 22 GOOD, clock 10:19. |
| | | Ithaca College 28, Utica 24 |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 41 yards, TOP 02:43 |
| | | Dan Tette kickoff 63 yards to the ITHACA2, R. D'Amico return 13 yards to the ITHACA15 (D. Sekuterski). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca15 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 10:14. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca15 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 24 yards to the ITHACA39, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Matthew McCoy). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca39 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 10 yards to the ITHACA49, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Matthew McCoy). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca49 | K. Anderson rush for 2 yards to the UTICA49 (Jack Derby;Keanu Heedram). |
| Ithaca | 2-8 | at Utica49 | W. Nabi pass complete to K. Anderson for 8 yards to the UTICA41, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Daryl Savage;A. Beaubrun), QB hurry by Kwasi Addo. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica41 | K. Anderson rush for 6 yards to the UTICA35 (A. Beaubrun). |
| Ithaca | 2-4 | at Utica35 | W. Nabi sacked for loss of 5 yards to the UTICA40 (Kwasi Addo). |
| Ithaca | 3-9 | at Utica40 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 13 yards to the UTICA27, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (A. Beaubrun;Dehstin Smart). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica27 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to J. Cooney, QB hurry by Jack Derby, PENALTY UTICA pass interference (Daryl Savage) 15 yards to the UTICA12, 1ST DOWN ITHACA, NO PLAY. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica12 | N. Cervone rush for no gain to the UTICA12 (Shane Walpole). |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Utica12 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to J. Cooney. |
| Ithaca | 3-10 | at Utica12 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to W. Gladney (Matthew McCoy), QB hurry by Robbie Schempp, PENALTY UTICA holding declined, PENALTY UTICA roughing passer (Robbie Schempp) 6 yards to the UTICA6, 1ST DOWN ITHACA, NO PLAY. |
| Ithaca | 1-G | at Utica06 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to A. Vito (Shane Walpole). |
| Ithaca | 2-G | at Utica06 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 6 yards to the UTICA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:55, B. Fallon kick attempt good. |
| | | Ithaca College 35, Utica 24 |
| Ithaca | 1-G | at Ithaca35 | PENALTY UTICA personal foul (Keanu Heedram) 15 yards to the 50 yardline. |
| Ithaca | 1-G | at Ithaca50 | PENALTY UTICA roughing holder (Keanu Heedram) 15 yards to the UTICA35. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 85 yards, TOP 03:19 |
| | | B. Fallon kickoff 35 yards to the UTICA0, touchback. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica25 | UTICA drive start at 06:55. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica25 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Brad Dougherty for 7 yards to the UTICA32 (P. Minogue;J. Long). |
| Utica | 2-3 | at Utica32 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Alex Damiani for 28 yards to the ITHACA40, 1ST DOWN UTICA (R. Silva;N. Garone). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca40 | Brad Dougherty rush for loss of 3 yards to the ITHACA43 (R. Silva;N. Garone), PENALTY ITHACA face mask (N. Garone) 15 yards to the ITHACA25, 1ST DOWN UTICA, NO PLAY. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca25 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Imani Vincent. |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Ithaca25 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Peyton Miller. |
| Utica | 3-10 | at Ithaca25 | Logan Wilcox sacked for loss of 8 yards to the ITHACA33 (B. Pacholec;N. Hill). |
| Utica | 4-18 | at Ithaca33 | PENALTY UTICA delay of game 5 yards to the ITHACA38. |
| Utica | 4-23 | at Ithaca38 | Maki Medici punt 36 yards to the ITHACA2, downed. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 37 yards, TOP 02:40 |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca02 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 04:15. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca02 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to A. Vito (Dehstin Smart). |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Ithaca02 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 31 yards to the ITHACA33, 1ST DOWN ITHACA, out-of-bounds (Dehstin Smart). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca33 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for no gain to the ITHACA33 (Antonio Scala). |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Ithaca33 | W. Nabi pass complete to A. Vito for 5 yards to the ITHACA38 (Kwasi Addo). |
| Ithaca | 3-5 | at Ithaca38 | W. Nabi pass complete to J. Jarvis for 4 yards to the ITHACA42 (Matthew McCoy). |
| Ithaca | 4-1 | at Ithaca42 | PENALTY ITHACA illegal shift 4 yards to the ITHACA38. |
| Ithaca | 4-5 | at Ithaca38 | P. Minogue punt 26 yards to the UTICA36, Nate Palmer return 0 yards to the UTICA36. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 36 yards, TOP 05:42 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica36 | Clock 02:02. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica36 | Peyton Miller rush for 1 yard to the UTICA37 (B. Gill). |
| Utica | 2-9 | at Utica37 | I. Washington rush for 7 yards to the UTICA44 (C. McDermott). |
| Utica | 3-2 | at Utica44 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Peyton Miller for 5 yards to the UTICA49, 1ST DOWN UTICA (B. Gill). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica49 | I. Washington rush for no gain to the UTICA49 (N. Garone;B. Pacholec). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 13 yards, TOP 01:27 |
| | | Ithaca College 35, Utica 24 |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Utica49 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Utica49 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Alex Damiani for 32 yards to the ITHACA19, 1ST DOWN UTICA (N. Garone;A. Francis). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca19 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Imani Vincent (A. Francis), PENALTY ITHACA offside (J. Long) 5 yards to the ITHACA14, NO PLAY. |
| Utica | 1-5 | at Ithaca14 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Peyton Miller. |
| Utica | 2-5 | at Ithaca14 | I. Washington rush for 1 yard to the ITHACA13 (A. Francis;R. Bronson). |
| Utica | 3-4 | at Ithaca13 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Josh Connor (J. Long). |
| Utica | 4-4 | at Ithaca13 | Maki Medici field goal attempt from 30 GOOD, clock 13:33. |
| | | Ithaca College 35, Utica 27 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 51 yards, TOP 01:27 |
| | | Dan Tette kickoff 53 yards to the ITHACA12, R. D'Amico return 35 yards to the ITHACA47 (Dan Tette). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca47 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 13:33. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca47 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to A. Vito. |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Ithaca47 | K. Anderson rush for 2 yards to the ITHACA49 (Keanu Heedram;M. Lott-Douglas). |
| Ithaca | 3-8 | at Ithaca49 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to H. Frey (Elijah Belle). |
| Ithaca | 4-8 | at Ithaca49 | P. Minogue punt 46 yards to the UTICA5, fair catch by Nate Palmer. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 01:04 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica05 | UTICA drive start at 12:29. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica05 | I. Washington rush for 1 yard to the UTICA6 (B. Gill). |
| Utica | 2-9 | at Utica06 | Logan Wilcox pass intercepted by J. Long at the UTICA42, J. Long return to the UTICA42, PENALTY ITHACA offside (H. Frey) 5 yards to the UTICA11, NO PLAY. |
| Utica | 2-4 | at Utica11 | PENALTY UTICA false start (Ryan McCormac) 5 yards to the UTICA6. |
| Utica | 2-9 | at Utica06 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Nate Palmer for 13 yards to the UTICA19, 1ST DOWN UTICA (N. Garone). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica19 | Brad Dougherty rush for no gain to the UTICA19 (N. Garone;A. Francis). |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Utica19 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Josh Connor for 81 yards to the ITHACA0, 1ST DOWN UTICA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:20, QB hurry by B. Gill. |
| Utica | 1-G | at Ithaca03 | PENALTY UTICA sideline interference 15 yards to the ITHACA18. |
| | | Maki Medici kick attempt failed. |
| | | Ithaca College 35, Utica 33 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 95 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Dan Tette kickoff 49 yards to the ITHACA16, R. D'Amico return 12 yards to the ITHACA28 (Joshua Fenical;John Nish). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca28 | Clock 10:15. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca28 | PENALTY ITHACA false start (W. Gladney) 5 yards to the ITHACA23. |
| Ithaca | 1-15 | at Ithaca23 | K. Anderson rush for 4 yards to the ITHACA27 (Robbie Schempp;Jack Derby). |
| Ithaca | 2-11 | at Ithaca27 | W. Nabi pass complete to A. Vito for 28 yards to the UTICA45, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Elijah Belle). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica45 | W. Nabi sacked for loss of 4 yards to the UTICA49 (Robbie Schempp). |
| Ithaca | 2-14 | at Utica49 | A. Vito rush for 5 yards to the UTICA44 (Kevin Chisari;Antonio Scala). |
| Ithaca | 3-9 | at Utica44 | W. Nabi pass complete to A. Vito for 7 yards to the UTICA37 (A. Beaubrun). |
| Ithaca | 4-2 | at Utica37 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 19 yards to the UTICA18, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Dehstin Smart). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica18 | W. Nabi pass complete to W. Gladney for 16 yards to the UTICA2, out-of-bounds, PENALTY ITHACA unsportsmanlike conduct (W. Gladney) 15 yards to the UTICA17. |
| Ithaca | 1-9 | at Utica17 | 1st and 9. |
| | | * Gladney disqualified for 2nd unsportsmanlike conduct penalty. |
| Ithaca | 1-9 | at Utica17 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to M. Hoffman. |
| Ithaca | 2-9 | at Utica17 | K. Anderson rush for 3 yards to the UTICA14 (Shane Walpole;Antonio Scala). |
| Ithaca | 3-6 | at Utica14 | W. Nabi pass intercepted by Elijah Belle at the UTICA16, Elijah Belle return 84 yards to the ITHACA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:01. |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 58 yards, TOP 04:19 |
| | | Logan Wilcox pass attempt to Peyton Miller good. |
| | | Utica 41, Ithaca College 35 |
| | | Dan Tette kickoff 55 yards to the ITHACA10, R. D'Amico return 21 yards to the ITHACA31 (Joshua Fenical;D. Sekuterski). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca31 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 05:56. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca31 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to J. Cooney (Shane Walpole). |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Ithaca31 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to M. Hoffman (Matthew McCoy). |
| Ithaca | 3-10 | at Ithaca31 | W. Nabi pass complete to J. Cooney for 13 yards to the ITHACA44, 1ST DOWN ITHACA, out-of-bounds (Dehstin Smart). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca44 | W. Nabi pass complete to H. Frey for 4 yards to the ITHACA48 (Elijah Belle). |
| Ithaca | 2-6 | at Ithaca48 | W. Nabi pass complete to H. Frey for 11 yards to the UTICA41, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Daryl Savage;A. Beaubrun). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica41 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to M. Hoffman. |
| Ithaca | 2-10 | at Utica41 | W. Nabi pass complete to N. Cervone for 12 yards to the UTICA29, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Daryl Savage;Kevin Chisari). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica29 | W. Nabi pass complete to J. Cooney for 7 yards to the UTICA22 (Kevin Chisari). |
| Ithaca | 2-3 | at Utica22 | W. Nabi pass incomplete to M. Hoffman (Elijah Belle). |
| Ithaca | 3-3 | at Utica22 | N. Cervone rush for 10 yards to the UTICA12, 1ST DOWN ITHACA (Dehstin Smart;Antonio Scala). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Utica12 | K. Anderson rush for 3 yards to the UTICA9 (A. Beaubrun;Daryl Savage). |
| Ithaca | 2-7 | at Utica09 | W. Nabi pass complete to A. Vito for 9 yards to the UTICA0, 1ST DOWN ITHACA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:54. |
| | | B. Fallon kick attempt good. |
| | | Ithaca College 42, Utica 41 |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 69 yards, TOP 03:11 |
| | | B. Fallon kickoff 55 yards to the UTICA10, Marquis Simpson return 22 yards to the UTICA32 (M. Haynes;D. Garcia). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica32 | UTICA drive start at 02:45. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica32 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Peyton Miller for 25 yards to the ITHACA43, 1ST DOWN UTICA (J. Long;C. McDermott). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca43 | Brad Dougherty rush for 4 yards to the ITHACA39 (N. Garone;P. Minogue). |
| Utica | 2-6 | at Ithaca39 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to Josh Connor for 4 yards to the ITHACA35 (J. Long). |
| Utica | 3-2 | at Ithaca35 | Logan Wilcox pass complete to J.J. O'Connor for 13 yards to the ITHACA22, 1ST DOWN UTICA (C. McDermott), QB hurry by J. Hadac. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca22 | Brad Dougherty rush for 3 yards to the ITHACA19 (J. Hadac;P. Minogue). |
| Utica | 2-7 | at Ithaca19 | Timeout Ithaca College, clock 01:03. |
| Utica | 2-7 | at Ithaca19 | Brad Dougherty rush for no gain to the ITHACA19 (B. Gill;B. Pacholec). |
| Utica | 3-7 | at Ithaca19 | Timeout Utica, clock 00:58. |
| Utica | 3-7 | at Ithaca19 | Logan Wilcox pass incomplete to Peyton Miller (P. Minogue). |
| Utica | 4-7 | at Ithaca19 | Maki Medici field goal attempt from 36 GOOD, clock 00:48. |
| | | Utica 44, Ithaca College 42 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 49 yards, TOP 02:02 |
| | | Dan Tette kickoff 55 yards to the ITHACA10, R. D'Amico return 19 yards to the ITHACA29 (Matt Wisnovsky). |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca29 | ITHACA COLLEGE drive start at 00:43. |
| Ithaca | 1-10 | at Ithaca29 | PENALTY ITHACA delay of game 5 yards to the ITHACA24. |
| Ithaca | 1-15 | at Ithaca24 | W. Nabi pass intercepted by Kwasi Addo at the ITHACA43, Kwasi Addo return -4 yards to the ITHACA47. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 5 yards, TOP 00:07 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca47 | UTICA drive start at 00:36. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Ithaca47 | TEAM rush for no gain to the ITHACA47. |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Ithaca47 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:36 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Utica 44, Ithaca College 42 |